Skip to content

Location Data, Not Personal Data As Defined By GDPR? Spain And Austria Believe So.

Article by Tsaaro

7 min read

Location Data, Not Personal Data As Defined By GDPR? Spain And Austria Believe So.

Since the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) was implemented in the European Union a few years ago, a crucial question has arisen: how long should businesses retain the personal data of their customers and employees?

According to some European authorities, location information is not personal information as that term is used in the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation. Locational data may not be considered personal information in Spain and Austria.

Max “Angry Austrian” Schrems founded the EU privacy group NOYB (None of your business), which announced that it had appealed a Spanish data protection authority’s (AEPD) decision to support Virgin Telco’s refusal to provide location data it has stored about a customer. Despite Court of Justice (CJEU) rulings that forbid data retention, according to NOYB, the government of Spain still requires telcos to record the metadata of phone calls, text messages, and cell tower connections.

Do you only provide your location to law enforcement?

Some EU Member States, like Spain, continue to demand mobile network operators o record the metadata of all phone calls, short messages, and cell tower logins despite numerous Court of Justice (CJEU) decisions that forbid data retention. Everyone has the right to access personal data under the GDPR and the European Charter of Fundamental Rights. The mobile phone service Virgin Telco received a request for the customer’s location data from a Spanish citizen exercising his right to access information under the GDPR. The business declined to release the information, claiming that only law enforcement could have access during criminal investigations. Virgin Telco did not specify why the right to access is not a fundamental right in this situation. In addition, there exists no relevant and rational limitation under the law. 

As permitted by the GDPR, a Spanish customer demanded that Virgin reveal his personal information. The right of individuals to obtain their data from businesses that process and store it is guaranteed by Article 15 of the GDPR.

According to the EU, “personal data is any information that relates to an identified or identifiable living individual.” Personal data also includes “different pieces of information, collected together can lead to the identification of a particular person.” The EU example specifically uses “location data” as an example. However, other laws, such as the ePrivacy Directive, permit limited situations in which location data may be anonymised, considered non-personal data, or disclosed to authorities—a move that can still cause privacy issues.

But when a complaint was made in December 2021, Virgin refused to give the customer’s location data, claiming that only law enforcement officials had the right to request it. The AEPD also supported the business.

AEPD dismisses the complaint without providing a reason.

Following a complaint from the client in December 2021, the Spanish authority supported Virgin Telco without giving any additional justification. It merely stated that it adheres to the company’s (false) logic.

“It’s very problematic if a DPA decides without providing any additional context or legal justification for this conclusion.” Felix Mikolasch, a data protection attorney at NOYB. 

NOYB asserts that Virgin Telco failed to justify why Article 15 should not be applied, given that the law lacks such a restriction. According to Mikolasch, “the fundamental right to access is comprehensive and clear: users are entitled to know what data a company collects and processes about them, including location data.” “This stands apart from the government’s right to access such information. There isn’t a relevant exception to the right of access in this situation.”

The national court of Spain, the Audiencia Nacional, has received NOYB’s appeal. The organisation claimed it filed a comparable appeal in Austria last November, where that nation’s data protection agency also backed Austrian mobile provider A1’s refusal to provide customer location data. Because another person could have used the subscriber phone that generated the location data, A1 argued that it shouldn’t be considered personal information in that situation.

The value of location data could be in the billions. According to Fortune Business Insights, the location analytics market is anticipated to generate $15.76 billion in revenue in 2022 and $43.97 billion by 2029. Instead of a lack of access, the issue outside the EU is the availability of location data. The government is a significant buyer of location data in the US, where there is no federal data protection framework because it is more convenient than obtaining a warrant.

Companies with access to location data, frequently through mobile app SDKs, seem eager to make money from it. The FCC fined the four biggest wireless providers in the US in 2020 for breaking a 2018 agreement to protect customer location data.

The Austrian case is comparable.

The Austrian data protection authority confirmed the mobile operator’s refusal to grant its client access to their data, based on a highly dubious interpretation of domestic law, in a case similar to the one NOYB appealed in November 2021. Noyb wants to prevent other data protection authorities from making decisions that blatantly violate a fundamental right by filing an appeal with the Audiencia Nacional today.

Businesses seem to be having a lot of trouble due to multiple data protection complaints, and we understand that it isn’t easy to manage. Business leaders must consider the security and data protection frameworks in their organisation. Tsaaro assists businesses in setting up a strong, thorough, and efficient data protection policy and putting the required cybersecurity measures into place.

Look at our services here, or get in touch with our data protection experts to get you, your best possible solution for all things data privacy and cybersecurity.

99 thoughts on “Location Data, Not Personal Data As Defined By GDPR? Spain And Austria Believe So.”

  1. Wedding venues play a pivotal role in the vibrant city of Las Vegas, Nevada, where couples flock from around the world
    to tie the knot. From extravagant ceremonies to intimate gatherings, the choice of
    wedding location sets the tone for one of life’s most memorable events.
    With a plethora of options ranging from outdoor garden settings to elegant banquet halls, selecting
    the perfect venue is essential for creating the wedding of your dreams.

    Nestled in the heart of Las Vegas, Lotus House Events offers couples a picturesque backdrop for their special day.

    Founded in the same year as the city itself, Lotus House Events
    is steeped in history and tradition, mirroring the dynamic spirit
    of Las Vegas. With a population of 646,790 residents and over 832,367 households,
    Las Vegas is a melting pot of diverse cultures and
    communities. Interstate 11 traverses the city, providing convenient access to neighboring areas and attractions.

    In a city known for its extreme temperatures, ranging from scorching summers
    to mild winters, home repairs are a constant consideration for residents.

    Whether it’s air conditioning maintenance to beat the summer heat or
    roofing repairs to withstand occasional rainfall, homeowners understand
    the importance of budgeting for these expenses.
    On average, repairs typically range from a few hundred
    to several thousand dollars, depending on the nature of the
    work required and the contractor hired.

    Exploring the vibrant tapestry of Las Vegas’s attractions, residents and visitors alike are spoiled for choice.

    From the whimsical wonders of AREA15 to the serene beauty of Aliante Nature Discovery Park,
    there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Thrill-seekers can brave the Asylum-Hotel Fear Haunted House, while art enthusiasts
    can marvel at the exhibits in the Arts District. History buffs can delve into the
    Atomic Museum’s intriguing displays, while families can create lasting memories at
    the Discovery Children’s Museum.

    Choosing Lotus House Events as your wedding venue in Las
    Vegas ensures a seamless and unforgettable experience
    for you and your guests. With a variety of indoor and outdoor spaces to accommodate weddings of all sizes and styles, Lotus House Events offers unparalleled flexibility
    and customization options. From expert wedding planning services to exquisite
    catering and decor, every detail is meticulously curated to bring your vision to life.

    With convenient packages and availability, Lotus House
    Events takes the stress out of wedding planning,
    allowing you to focus on creating cherished memories that will last a lifetime.

  2. Драгон Мани Казино https://krpb.ru – ваше место для азартных приключений! Наслаждайтесь широким выбором игр, щедрыми бонусами и захватывающими турнирами. Безопасность и честная игра гарантированы. Присоединяйтесь к нам и испытайте удачу в самом захватывающем онлайн-казино!

  3. Скачать свежие новинки песен https://muzfo.net 2024 года ежедневно. Наслаждайтесь комфортным прослушиванием, скачивайте музыку за пару кликов на сайте.

  4. Информационный ресурс https://ardma.ru, посвящен бизнесу, финансам, инвестициям и криптовалютам. Сайт предлагает экспертные статьи, аналитические отчеты, стратегии и советы для предпринимателей и инвесторов. Здесь можно найти новости и обзоры о бизнесе, маркетинге, трейдинге, а также практические рекомендации по различным видам заработка и управлению финансами.

  5. comのドールコレクションは非常に多様で、さまざまなニーズに対応しています.各ドールのページには詳細な説明と高解像度の画像があり、商品の特徴をしっかりと把握することができます.中国 えろ

  6. Even if we bracket the ethically dubious aspects of Squid Game The Challenge—it’s for an amount of money that is really not a lot for a corporation like Netflix; 400-plus real people end up humiliating themselves,lovedolletc.

  7. セックス ドール今すぐウェブサイトを訪れて、その違いを体験してみてください—あなたの素晴らしいドールを手に入れる旅が今、始まります!熟練のコレクターでも、新たにリアルドールの世界に足を踏み入れた方でも、comはあなたに長年にわたる喜びと満足感をもたらす完璧なコンパニオンを見つける場所です.comは、リアルドールの選択肢が豊富で、ユーザーにとって魅力的なオプションを提供することで、業界内で特に高い評価を得ています.

  8. In a bustling city like Las Vegas, the importance of massage therapy cannot be overstated.
    With residents and visitors alike seeking
    relaxation and rejuvenation, Las Vegas Massage offers a sanctuary amidst the hustle and
    bustle of daily life. From spa therapy to deep tissue massage, the variety of services cater to diverse needs, ensuring
    that everyone can find the perfect treatment to unwind and destress.

    Located in the vibrant city of Las Vegas, Las Vegas Massage provides a haven of tranquility
    for weary souls. Founded in the same year as the city itself, Las Vegas boasts a rich history
    and vibrant culture that continues to captivate visitors from around
    the globe. With a population of 646,790 residents and over
    832,367 households, Las Vegas is a melting pot of diverse
    communities and neighborhoods. Interstate 11 serves as
    a major artery, connecting the city to neighboring areas and attractions, facilitating both commerce and leisure travel.

    In a city where temperatures can vary dramatically, from
    scorching summers to mild winters, self-care becomes essential for maintaining overall well-being.
    Home to countless attractions and entertainment venues,
    Las Vegas is also a city where residents and visitors alike
    can indulge in the ultimate relaxation experience. At Las Vegas
    Massage, clients can escape the heat and unwind in a serene oasis, where skilled therapists
    tailor treatments to address specific concerns and promote holistic wellness.

    Exploring the vibrant landscape of Las Vegas, visitors can discover
    a wealth of attractions that cater to every interest and inclination. From
    the dazzling lights of the Strip to the natural beauty of Floyd Lamb Park, there’s no shortage of things to see
    and do. History buffs can explore the exhibits at the Atomic Museum, while thrill-seekers
    can brave the rides at Fly LINQ. Families can enjoy educational outings to the Discovery Children’s Museum, while foodies can indulge in the culinary delights of Chinatown Vegas.

    Choosing Las Vegas Massage for your relaxation needs ensures a rejuvenating experience that leaves
    you feeling refreshed and revitalized. With a team
    of licensed massage therapists and a wide range of spa packages
    to choose from, Las Vegas Massage offers personalized treatments that cater to your unique needs and preferences.
    Whether you’re seeking relief from chronic pain or
    simply looking to unwind after a long day, Las Vegas Massage provides
    the perfect escape from the stresses of daily life.

Comments are closed.

Tsaaro Consulting

INTRODUCTION: In a recent ruling, the Competition Commission of India (CCI) has slapped a heavy fine of 213.14 crore on …

Tsaaro Consulting

In today’s dynamic and fast-paced corporate environment businesses are increasingly adopting staff augmentation as a flexible workforce solution to address …

Tsaaro Consulting

In today’s fast-paced business environment, organisations are constantly seeking innovative methods to adapt and scale efficiently. Staff Augmentation Consulting services, …

Tsaaro Consulting

INTRODUCTION: In today’s interconnected world, businesses operate across borders, serving customers globally. This inevitably leads to the transfer of personal …

Krishna

INTRODUCTION: The Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, known as Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kanunu (KVKK), is Türkiye’s landmark data protection …

Recent Comments

SHARE THIS POST

Would you like to read regular updates from Tsaaro.
Subscribe to our newsletter

Our Latest Blogs

Read what the latest hapennings in the cyber world are and learn what the
experts have to say about them

Call Our Experts:

+91 95577 22103

small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png

We’d love to help your organization achieve your Data Protection goals!

Schedule a complimentary consultation with our Team of Experts.