Skip to content
Schedule a Call
Call Now

What does the EU-US Data Agreement entail for privacy?

Article by Tsaaro

7 min read

What does the EU-US Data Agreement entail for privacy?

The United States (“US”) and the European Commission (“EU”) had agreed to create a new Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework to promote trans-Atlantic data flows and address concerns raised by the European Union’s Court of Justice (“CJEU”) when it overturned the Commission’s adequacy decision underlying the EU-US Privacy Shield framework in 2020.

This Framework would reinstate a crucial legal mechanism for transferring personal data from the EU to the US. The US has committed to implementing new safeguards to ensure that signals intelligence activities are necessary and proportionate in the pursuit of defined national security objectives, providing the privacy of EU personal data, and creating a new mechanism for EU individuals to seek redress if they believe signals intelligence activities have unlawfully targeted them. 

A brief overview of past events 

The conflict originates from a complaint submitted over a decade ago by Austrian lawyer and privacy campaigner Max Schrems, who was concerned about how Facebook handled his data in light of revelations about U.S. government cyberespionage by former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden.

Along the way, the EU’s top court also ruled that the Privacy Shield deal protecting transatlantic data transfers was invalid because it violated the 27-nation bloc’s stringent data privacy requirements. Companies were compelled to rely on legal stock contracts to continue the transfers. The debate had raised the possibility that Facebook might have to redesign its data centres to keep European data out of the United States.

What does the new EU-US Data Agreement entail?

The new Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework will enable an equitable and competitive digital economy and establish the groundwork for future economic cooperation by ensuring a permanent and reliable legal framework for data flows. It addresses the European Union’s Court of Justice’s Schrems II judgement about US legislation governing signals intelligence activities. The United States has made extraordinary promises under the Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework to:

  1. Enhance the privacy and civil rights measures that govern the US signals intelligence activities;
  2. Create a new redress system with independent and binding authority; and
  3. Improve its current, thorough and multi-layered oversight of signals intelligence activities.

 

For example, the new Framework ensures that:

  1. Signal intelligence collection may be carried out only when necessary to achieve legitimate national security objectives, and it must not have a disproportionate impact on individual privacy and civil freedoms.
  2. EU citizens may seek redress through a new multi-tiered redress structure that comprises an independent Data Protection Review Court comprised of individuals recruited from outside the US government who would have full ability to assess allegations and direct remedial measures as necessary; and
  3. Intelligence agencies in the United States will implement processes to assure effective oversight of new privacy and civil liberties requirements.

 

Benefits of the Agreement

Citizens on both sides of the Atlantic will gain significantly from this Framework. The agreement includes –

  1. New, high-standard pledges to protect personal data for EU citizens. 
  2. It will allow citizens and businesses on both sides of the Atlantic to continue the flow of data that underlies more than $1 trillion in cross-border commerce each year, as well as 
  3. It also allows firms of all sizes to compete in marketplaces. 

 

It is the result of more than a year of thorough negotiations between the EU and the US following a 2020 decision by the CJEU stating that the previous EU-US arrangement, known as Privacy Shield, did not meet EU legal criteria.

The new Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework highlights mutual commitment to privacy, data protection, the rule of law, and collective security, as well as a mutual understanding of the importance of trans-Atlantic data, flows to respective citizens economies, and societies in the EU-US region. 

Data transfers are crucial to the trans-Atlantic economic relationship and all large and small enterprises in all industries. In reality, more data moves between the United States and Europe than anywhere else, allowing the $7.1 trillion US-EU economic connection to function.

The Way Forward

Participating enterprises and organisations using the Framework to protect data flows legally will be required to continue adhering to the Privacy Shield Principles, including self-certification through the US Department of Commerce.

Individuals in the EU will continue to have various options for resolving complaints about participating organisations, including alternative dispute resolution and binding arbitration.

The US intelligence community will execute these new principles to effectively protect its citizens and those of its friends and partners, following the high-standard protections provided by this Framework.

The US government and the European Commission teams will now work together to translate this agreement into legal documents that must be signed by both parties to put in place this new Trans-Atlantic Data Privacy Framework. These promises from the United States will be placed in an Executive Order that will serve as the foundation for the Commission’s assessment in its future sufficiency judgement.

Conclusion

According to Facebook’s head of global affairs, Nick Clegg, the new agreement “will help keep people connected and services running.” “It will provide invaluable certainty for American and European businesses of all sizes, including Meta, that rely on data transfer quickly and safely.” Google has praised the EU and US efforts to “protect transatlantic data transfers.”

However, Schrems described the latest agreement as a “political announcement.” He warned that it could end up in court because his Vienna-based group NOYB would thoroughly examine it and challenge anything that violated EU law. 

Thus, as the agreement was only struck “in principle,” there appears to be some ambiguity, and we may have to wait a while before seeing the final text. Even optimistic views persist among privacy specialists who commend the negotiators’ efforts and are eager to ensure that organisations continue to be accredited to the expanded Privacy Shield.

 

 

303 thoughts on “What does the EU-US Data Agreement entail for privacy?”

  2. TimothyBerve
    Reply

    Главные новости мира https://ua-vestnik.com и страны: политика, экономика, спорт, культура, технологии. Оперативная информация, аналитика и эксклюзивные материалы для тех, кто следит за событиями в реальном времени.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

draft dpdp rules 2025
Understanding Data Principal Rights Under DPDPA, 2023 and Draft DPDP Rules, 2025
Tsaaro Consulting

Understanding Data Principal Rights Under DPDPA, 2023 and Draft DPDP Rules, 2025

Introduction: Data protection laws worldwide empower individuals, referred to as ‘Data Subjects’ under the GDPR or ‘Data Principals’ under India’s …

•
January 9, 2025
DPDP Rules
Understanding Data Retention in Compliance with DPDPA and Draft DPDP Rules
Tsaaro Consulting

Understanding Data Retention in Compliance with DPDPA and Draft DPDP Rules

In today’s fast-paced, data-driven world, businesses collect large amounts of data and store such information regularly. This data is extremely …

•
January 8, 2025
Protecting Children’s Data: Understanding Verifiable Parental Consent and Prohibition on Behavioural Monitoring Under the DPDPA and Draft DPDP Rules
Tsaaro Consulting

Protecting Children’s Data: Understanding Verifiable Parental Consent and Prohibition on Behavioural Monitoring Under the DPDPA and Draft DPDP Rules

In an increasingly digital world, society today is growing around technology that tends to collect and process a large amount …

•
January 6, 2025
draft dpdp rules
Guardians of Privacy: Understanding the Functioning of Consent Managers under the DPDP Act and the Draft DPDP Rules, 2025
Tsaaro Consulting

Guardians of Privacy: Understanding the Functioning of Consent Managers under the DPDP Act and the Draft DPDP Rules, 2025

Introduction  It was the Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019 that introduced the concept of “Consent Manager”. In the 2019 Bill, …

•
January 4, 2025
dpdp rules
Ensuring Informed Consent: A Deep Dive into Consent Notice Requirements Under the DPDPA and Draft DPDP Rules, 2025
Tsaaro Consulting

Ensuring Informed Consent: A Deep Dive into Consent Notice Requirements Under the DPDPA and Draft DPDP Rules, 2025

Introduction In 2023, a significant milestone was achieved with the enactment of India’s long-awaited data protection law, the Digital Personal …

•
January 4, 2025
Recent Comments

SHARE THIS POST

Would you like to read regular updates from Tsaaro.
Subscribe to our newsletter

Our Latest Blogs

Read what the latest hapennings in the cyber world are and learn what the
experts have to say about them

© 2024 Tsaaro Consulting. All rights reserved.
Linkedin Instagram Youtube

About Tsaaro

Resources

Other Links

Tsaaro Netherlands Office

Regus Schiphol Rijk Beech Avenue 54-62, Het Poortgebouw, Amsterdam, 1119 PW, Netherlands

Tsaaro Pune Office

Tech Centre, Rajiv Gandhi Infotech Park, Hinjewadi, Pune, Maharashtra

Tsaaro Noida Office

302, Tower C, ATS Bouquet, Noida Sector – 132, Uttar Pradesh, India

Tsaaro Bengaluru Office I

Manyata, Embassy Business Park, Outer Ring Road, Bengaluru, Karnataka

Tsaaro Bengaluru Office II

Second State, CMH Road, Indiranagar, Bengaluru, Karnataka

Call Our Experts:

+91 95577 22103

small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png
small_c_popup.png